Maithan Alloys Ltd. Upgraded to Sell on Improved Technicals and Fair Valuation

Technical Trends Shift to Mildly Bullish

The most significant catalyst for the rating upgrade is the change in Maithan Alloys’ technical grade, which moved from mildly bearish to mildly bullish. Weekly technical indicators such as the Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD) and Bollinger Bands have turned positive, signalling potential upward momentum. Specifically, the weekly MACD is mildly bullish, supported by bullish Bollinger Bands and On-Balance Volume (OBV) trends, which suggest increasing buying interest.

However, the monthly technical picture remains mixed, with the MACD and Dow Theory indicators still mildly bearish. The Relative Strength Index (RSI) on both weekly and monthly charts shows no clear signal, indicating a neutral momentum in the short term. Daily moving averages remain mildly bearish, reflecting some near-term caution among traders.

Overall, the technical landscape suggests a tentative recovery in price action, with the stock currently trading at ₹1,069.60, down 1.92% on the day but showing positive returns over recent weeks and months. Notably, Maithan Alloys outperformed the Sensex over the past week (+5.79% vs. -1.69%) and month (+12.45% vs. -1.92%), reinforcing the mild bullish technical stance.

Valuation Moves from Attractive to Fair

Alongside technical improvements, Maithan Alloys’ valuation grade has been revised from attractive to fair. The company currently trades at a price-to-earnings (PE) ratio of 7.00, which is modest but higher than its previous valuation level. Its price-to-book value stands at 0.76, indicating the stock is priced below its book value but closer to fair value territory.

Enterprise value multiples also reflect this shift, with EV to EBIT at 7.57 and EV to EBITDA at 6.66, suggesting the market is factoring in some operational challenges. The company’s return on capital employed (ROCE) is 7.57%, while return on equity (ROE) is 10.79%, both moderate figures that support the fair valuation stance.

Compared to peers in the ferro and silica manganese industry, Maithan Alloys is valued more reasonably. For instance, Indian Metals, a sector peer, trades at a significantly higher PE of 20.03 and EV to EBIT of 13.02, categorised as very expensive. This relative valuation gap underpins the fair grade assigned to Maithan Alloys.

Financial Trend Remains Negative Amidst Operational Struggles

Despite the upgrade in technical and valuation parameters, Maithan Alloys’ financial trend remains a concern. The company reported very negative results for Q2 FY25-26, with net sales declining by 22.38% year-on-year. Operating profit has contracted at an annualised rate of -2.65% over the past five years, signalling persistent operational headwinds.

Profit after tax (PAT) for the quarter plunged to a loss of ₹120.95 crore, a dramatic fall of 168.2% compared to the previous four-quarter average. Interest expenses have surged to ₹13.97 crore, the highest recorded, while the operating profit to interest coverage ratio has dropped to a low of 2.30 times, indicating increased financial strain.

These figures highlight the challenges Maithan Alloys faces in sustaining profitability and managing costs effectively. The company’s low debt-to-equity ratio, averaging zero, suggests limited leverage, but this has not translated into improved earnings performance.

Institutional interest remains muted, with domestic mutual funds holding no stake in the company. Given their capacity for detailed research, this absence may reflect concerns about the company’s current valuation or business outlook.

Technical and Valuation Improvements Temper Long-Term Concerns

While the financial trend is negative, the upgrade to Sell from Strong Sell reflects a more balanced view. The technical indicators’ shift to mildly bullish and the move to a fair valuation grade suggest that the stock may be stabilising after a prolonged period of weakness.

Maithan Alloys’ stock has delivered a 6.94% return over the past year, outperforming the Sensex’s 9.56% gain only marginally, but its long-term returns remain impressive. Over ten years, the stock has surged by 968.53%, vastly outpacing the Sensex’s 236.47% rise. However, the recent profit decline tempers enthusiasm for near-term growth prospects.

Investors should weigh the company’s improving technical signals and reasonable valuation against its deteriorating earnings and operational challenges. The stock’s 52-week range of ₹834.05 to ₹1,265.00 reflects significant volatility, underscoring the need for cautious appraisal.

Quality Assessment and Market Position

Maithan Alloys operates within the ferro and silica manganese industry, a segment characterised by cyclical demand and commodity price volatility. The company’s quality grade remains challenged by its recent financial performance, with operating profit contraction and a sharp PAT decline signalling structural issues.

Its market capitalisation grade stands at 3, reflecting a mid-sized presence in the sector. The company’s Mojo Score is 44.0, categorised as Sell, an improvement from the previous Strong Sell rating but still indicative of caution. This score integrates multiple factors including financial health, valuation, and technical trends.

Despite the current rating, Maithan Alloys’ long-term stock performance remains noteworthy. Over a decade, the stock has delivered returns of 968.53%, significantly outperforming the Sensex’s 236.47%. This suggests that while short-term fundamentals are weak, the company has historically generated substantial shareholder value.

Conclusion: A Cautious Upgrade Amid Mixed Signals

The upgrade of Maithan Alloys Ltd. from Strong Sell to Sell reflects a complex interplay of factors. Technical indicators have improved, signalling a potential stabilisation or mild recovery in the stock price. Valuation metrics have shifted from attractive to fair, indicating the market is beginning to price in some of the company’s challenges more realistically.

However, the financial trend remains negative, with significant declines in sales and profitability, and rising interest costs. The lack of institutional ownership further underscores investor scepticism. For investors, this rating change suggests a cautious approach: the stock may offer some upside from technical and valuation perspectives, but fundamental risks persist.

Careful monitoring of upcoming quarterly results and sector dynamics will be essential to reassess the company’s outlook. For now, Maithan Alloys remains a Sell-rated stock with potential for recovery if operational performance improves and technical momentum sustains.

Unlock special upgrade rates for a limited period. Start Saving Now →