Star Paper Mills Downgraded to Strong Sell Amid Valuation and Financial Concerns

Valuation Upgrade Masks Underlying Concerns

Despite the overall downgrade in investment rating, Star Paper Mills has experienced an upgrade in its valuation grade from "Very Attractive" to "Attractive." The company currently trades at a price-to-earnings (PE) ratio of 5.83, which remains low compared to industry peers, indicating a relatively inexpensive stock price relative to earnings. The price-to-book value stands at a modest 0.32, further underscoring the stock's undervaluation. Enterprise value multiples such as EV/EBITDA (-0.73) and EV/EBIT (-0.94) are negative, reflecting accounting anomalies or losses that complicate traditional valuation metrics.

Dividend yield at 2.43% offers some income appeal, while the return on equity (ROE) of 5.50% and return on capital employed (ROCE) remain subdued, with ROCE impacted by negative capital employed figures. Compared to peers like Pudumjee Paper and Kuantum Papers, which trade at higher multiples, Star Paper Mills appears attractively priced, but this valuation advantage is tempered by operational weaknesses and financial instability.

Financial Trend Deterioration Raises Red Flags

Star Paper Mills’ recent financial performance has been disappointing. The company reported negative results in Q2 FY25-26, with operating cash flow at a low ₹14.84 crores and profit before tax (PBT) declining by 28.84% to ₹5.28 crores. Net profit after tax (PAT) for the nine months ended September 2025 fell by 27.93% to ₹30.84 crores, signalling weakening profitability.

Long-term growth metrics also paint a concerning picture. Over the past five years, net sales have grown at a modest annual rate of 10.03%, while operating profit growth has lagged at 7.54%. These figures fall short of industry averages and suggest limited expansion potential. The company’s return on equity averaged 8.58%, indicating poor management efficiency in generating shareholder value.

Moreover, promoter share pledging remains high at 47.21%, which could exert additional downward pressure on the stock price in volatile markets, raising governance and liquidity concerns.

Quality Metrics Reflect Operational Challenges

Star Paper Mills’ quality assessment remains weak, contributing to the downgrade. The company’s ROE of 8.58% is below industry standards, indicating inefficient utilisation of equity capital. The negative capital employed figure adversely affects ROCE, signalling potential balance sheet stress or asset write-downs.

Long-term growth rates for sales and operating profit are below sector averages, and the company’s management efficiency is questioned given the low profitability per unit of shareholder funds. These factors collectively weigh on the company’s quality grade, which remains poor despite the valuation upgrade.

Technical Indicators and Market Performance

Technically, Star Paper Mills has underperformed the broader market indices and its sector peers. The stock has generated a negative return of 22.16% over the past year, compared to a 5.16% gain in the Sensex. Over three years, the stock’s return of -17.45% starkly contrasts with the Sensex’s 35.67% appreciation, highlighting sustained underperformance.

Recent trading activity shows limited volatility, with the stock price hovering near its 52-week low of ₹140.00 and a current price of ₹144.00. The day’s price change was a modest 0.56%, reflecting subdued investor interest. The low debt-to-equity ratio, averaging zero, suggests minimal leverage but also limited financial flexibility to drive growth or weather downturns.

Comparative Industry Context

Within the Paper, Forest & Jute Products sector, Star Paper Mills’ valuation metrics remain attractive relative to peers such as String Metaverse, which is classified as "Very Expensive" with a PE ratio of 57.45, and T N Newsprint, rated "Very Attractive" but trading at a higher PE of 30.55. However, the company’s negative EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA multiples contrast with positive multiples for competitors, reflecting operational losses or accounting peculiarities.

While some peers like Pudumjee Paper and Satia Industries maintain attractive valuations with better profitability metrics, Star Paper Mills’ weak financial trends and poor management efficiency undermine its investment appeal despite the valuation edge.

Summary and Outlook

Star Paper Mills Ltd.’s downgrade to a Strong Sell rating by MarketsMOJO on 1 February 2026 is driven by a combination of factors. Although the valuation grade improved from very attractive to attractive, this was insufficient to offset deteriorating financial trends, poor quality metrics, and negative technical signals. The company’s declining profitability, negative cash flow trends, and high promoter share pledging raise significant concerns about its near-term prospects.

Investors should weigh the stock’s low valuation against its operational challenges and market underperformance. The company’s inability to generate consistent returns on equity and capital employed, coupled with shrinking profits and sales growth below sector averages, suggests caution. Until Star Paper Mills demonstrates a turnaround in financial health and management effectiveness, the Strong Sell rating remains justified.

Unlock special upgrade rates for a limited period. Start Saving Now →