Is Shriram AMC overvalued or undervalued?

Valuation Metrics and Profitability Concerns

Shriram AMC’s valuation grade has recently shifted to “very expensive,” reflecting heightened market expectations. The company’s price-to-book value stands at 4.12, which is considerably high for the capital markets sector. More strikingly, the price-to-earnings (PE) ratio is negative, indicating losses rather than profits. This is corroborated by the negative return on capital employed (ROCE) of -10.85% and return on equity (ROE) of -10.79%, signalling operational challenges and weak profitability.

Enterprise value multiples such as EV to EBIT and EV to EBITDA are also negative, reinforcing the notion that earnings are currently under pressure. Meanwhile, the EV to sales ratio is extremely elevated at 73.62, suggesting that investors are paying a premium for each rupee of sales generated. The PEG ratio is zero, which typically indicates no earnings growth or negative earnings, further complicating valuation assessments.

Peer Comparison Highlights

When compared with peers in the capital markets and financial services sectors, Shriram AMC’s valuation appears stretched. While companies like Bajaj Finance and Bajaj Finserv are also rated as expensive or very expensive, their positive PE ratios and PEG ratios above 1.5 reflect earnings growth and profitability that Shriram AMC currently lacks. Life insurance companies such as SBI Life Insurance and Life Insurance Corporation are rated as very attractive or fair, with more reasonable valuation multiples and positive earnings metrics.

This disparity suggests that Shriram AMC’s high valuation is not supported by fundamentals relative to its peers. The company’s negative earnings and returns contrast sharply with the positive financial health of other industry players, raising questions about the sustainability of its current market price.

Stock Price Performance and Market Sentiment

Shriram AMC’s stock price has experienced significant volatility over the past year. The current price of ₹395 is well below its 52-week high of ₹694.60, reflecting a substantial correction. Year-to-date, the stock has declined by over 31%, underperforming the Sensex, which has gained more than 9% in the same period. Even over the past month and week, Shriram AMC’s returns have been negative, while the broader market has shown resilience.

However, the longer-term returns tell a different story. Over three, five, and ten years, Shriram AMC has delivered exceptional gains, outperforming the Sensex by a wide margin. This suggests that while the company has faced recent headwinds, its historical performance has been robust, possibly justifying some premium valuation in the past.

Balancing Valuation with Future Prospects

Despite the current expensive valuation and negative profitability metrics, investors may be pricing in a turnaround or future growth potential. The capital markets industry is dynamic, and asset management companies can benefit from rising assets under management and favourable market conditions. Yet, the absence of dividend yield and the negative earnings indicators warrant caution.

Investors should weigh the risks of overvaluation against the possibility of operational improvements and market recovery. Given the current data, Shriram AMC appears overvalued relative to its earnings and peer group, but its long-term track record and market position may offer some justification for a premium.

Conclusion: Overvalued with Caveats

In conclusion, Shriram AMC’s current valuation metrics and negative profitability indicators suggest that the stock is overvalued at present. The market appears to be pricing in expectations that have yet to materialise in earnings or returns. Compared to its peers, the company’s multiples are stretched without the backing of positive financial performance.

However, the company’s strong long-term returns and potential for future growth mean that investors should not dismiss it outright. Careful monitoring of earnings improvements, market conditions, and asset growth will be essential for assessing whether the premium valuation can be justified going forward.

For investors seeking more stable or attractively valued opportunities, exploring alternatives within the capital markets and financial services sectors may be prudent at this juncture.

Get 2 full years of MojoOne Premium for only Rs. 12,999. Subscribe for 1 year and we'll add another year FREE. Offer valid for a limited time. Start Saving Now →