Is Shukra Jewellery overvalued or undervalued?

Valuation Metrics Indicate Undervaluation

Shukra Jewellery’s price-to-earnings (PE) ratio stands at approximately 24.7, which is significantly lower than many of its industry peers such as Titan Company and Kalyan Jewellers, whose PE ratios exceed 50. This lower PE ratio suggests that the market is pricing Shukra Jewellery’s earnings more conservatively, potentially reflecting concerns about growth or profitability. However, when combined with its price-to-book value of just 0.36, the stock appears to be trading well below its net asset value, a classic indicator of undervaluation.

Further supporting this view, the company’s enterprise value to EBITDA ratio is around 13, which is markedly lower than the ratios of several competitors that range from 14 to over 50. This implies that Shukra Jewellery’s operational earnings are valued more cheaply relative to its enterprise value, enhancing its appeal from a valuation standpoint.

Profitability and Returns Remain Modest

Despite the attractive valuation, Shukra Jewellery’s return on capital employed (ROCE) and return on equity (ROE) are notably low, at just over 1%. These figures indicate that the company is generating limited returns on the capital invested, which may explain the cautious market sentiment. Investors should weigh this modest profitability against the valuation discount to assess whether the company’s fundamentals justify a higher price.

Stock Price and Market Performance

The stock currently trades near ₹9.64, down from its 52-week high of ₹17.24 but above its low of ₹7.25. This wide trading range reflects volatility and market uncertainty. Over the past year, Shukra Jewellery’s stock has declined by over 22%, underperforming the broader Sensex index, which has gained around 8%. However, over a longer horizon of ten years, the stock has delivered a robust cumulative return exceeding 250%, outperforming the Sensex’s 228% gain, highlighting its potential for long-term investors.

Peer Comparison Highlights Relative Value

When compared with its peers in the gems and jewellery sector, Shukra Jewellery’s valuation stands out as very attractive. Titan Company, a market leader, trades at a PE ratio more than three times higher, while other notable players like Kalyan Jewellers and Thangamayil Jewellery are considered expensive based on their valuation multiples. This disparity suggests that Shukra Jewellery may be undervalued relative to its industry, offering a potential margin of safety for investors.

However, it is important to note that some peers with lower valuations, such as PC Jeweller, also carry risks, including profitability concerns. Shukra Jewellery’s low PEG ratio of 0.07 further indicates that its price is low relative to its earnings growth potential, a positive sign for value investors.

Risks and Considerations

Despite the attractive valuation, investors should be cautious given the company’s weak profitability metrics and recent stock price volatility. The absence of a dividend yield may also deter income-focused investors. Additionally, the company’s year-to-date stock return has been negative, contrasting with the broader market’s positive performance, which may reflect sector-specific challenges or company-specific issues.

Conclusion: Undervalued but with Caveats

In summary, Shukra Jewellery appears undervalued based on key valuation metrics such as PE ratio, price-to-book value, and EV/EBITDA compared to its peers. The recent upgrade to a very attractive valuation grade reinforces this view. However, the company’s low returns on capital and equity, combined with recent underperformance relative to the Sensex, suggest that investors should approach with caution and consider the underlying fundamentals carefully.

For value-oriented investors willing to tolerate some operational challenges, Shukra Jewellery could represent a compelling opportunity, especially given its long-term track record of outperformance. Nonetheless, monitoring profitability improvements and market conditions will be crucial before committing significant capital.

Get 2 full years of MojoOne Premium for only Rs. 12,999. Subscribe for 1 year and we'll add another year FREE. Offer valid for a limited time. Start Saving Now →