Why is ESAF Small Fin falling/rising?

Recent Price Movement and Market Context

The stock has been under significant pressure, losing 7.18% over the past week compared to a modest 0.63% decline in the Sensex. Over the last month, ESAF Small Finance Bank’s shares have fallen by 10.05%, while the Sensex gained 2.27%. Year-to-date, the stock has plummeted 41.22%, starkly contrasting with the Sensex’s 8.91% rise. This underperformance extends over the one-year horizon as well, with ESAF Small Finance Bank’s shares down 40.86% against a 4.15% gain in the benchmark index.

On the day of 08-Dec, the stock traded close to its 52-week low, just 1.46% above the lowest price of ₹24.35. Intraday, it touched a low of ₹24.7, reflecting a 5.47% drop. The weighted average price indicates that a larger volume of shares exchanged hands near the day’s low, signalling selling pressure. Additionally, the stock is trading below all key moving averages, including the 5-day, 20-day, 50-day, 100-day, and 200-day averages, underscoring a bearish technical outlook.

Fundamental Weaknesses Driving the Decline

ESAF Small Finance Bank’s share price decline is primarily rooted in its deteriorating financial health. The bank’s capital adequacy ratio stands at a concerning 0%, indicating a lack of sufficient capital buffers to absorb potential losses from its risk-weighted assets. This exposes the institution to heightened financial vulnerability and investor scepticism.

Cost management has also been a persistent issue, with the bank reporting a high cost-to-income ratio of 80.70%. Such inefficiency in controlling operating expenses weighs heavily on profitability and investor confidence. The bank’s recent quarterly results have been negative for seven consecutive quarters, signalling ongoing operational challenges.

Specifically, the net interest income (NII) for the latest quarter was at a low of ₹364.06 crore, while interest earned declined by 10.5% compared to the average of the previous four quarters, standing at ₹819.82 crore. Furthermore, the gross non-performing assets (NPA) ratio has reached a peak of 8.54%, reflecting a rising level of stressed assets that could impair future earnings.

With a return on assets (ROA) of -2.2%, the bank is currently unprofitable. Despite this, the stock trades at a price-to-book value of 0.7, which is relatively expensive compared to peers’ historical valuations. This disconnect between valuation and fundamentals likely contributes to the negative sentiment among investors.

Adding to concerns, domestic mutual funds hold no stake in ESAF Small Finance Bank, a notable omission given their capacity for thorough research and due diligence. Their absence may indicate a lack of confidence in the bank’s business prospects or valuation at current levels.

Long-Term Underperformance and Investor Sentiment

Over the longer term, ESAF Small Finance Bank has underperformed key market indices and sector benchmarks. While the BSE500 index has delivered positive returns over the past three years, the bank’s stock has failed to generate comparable gains. This sustained underperformance has likely eroded investor trust and contributed to the ongoing sell-off.

The stock’s recent two-day consecutive decline has resulted in a cumulative loss of 6.47%, with rising delivery volumes signalling increased investor participation in the sell-off. Despite adequate liquidity to support trading, the prevailing negative sentiment has kept the stock under pressure.

In summary, ESAF Small Finance Bank’s share price decline on 08-Dec is a reflection of its weak capital position, deteriorating asset quality, poor cost control, and sustained negative earnings. These fundamental challenges, combined with the stock’s underperformance relative to market benchmarks and absence of institutional backing, have culminated in significant investor caution and selling pressure.

Get 2 full years of MojoOne Premium for only Rs. 12,999. Subscribe for 1 year and we'll add another year FREE. Offer valid for a limited time. Start Saving Now →