Why is West Coast Paper falling/rising?

Recent Price Movement and Market Context

West Coast Paper’s stock has been on a downward trajectory over the past week, falling by 2.41%, while the broader Sensex index gained 0.79% in the same period. This negative trend extends over longer horizons as well, with the stock declining 9.01% in the last month and a significant 24.28% year-to-date, contrasting sharply with the Sensex’s positive returns of 0.95% and 9.08% respectively. Over the past year, the stock has lost 22.75%, whereas the Sensex has appreciated by 10.47%. Even over three years, West Coast Paper has underperformed substantially, with a 28.41% decline compared to the Sensex’s 39.39% gain.

On the day in question, the stock’s performance was in line with its sector peers, yet it has been falling for two consecutive days, accumulating a 1.72% loss during this period. The share price is trading below all key moving averages, including the 5-day, 20-day, 50-day, 100-day, and 200-day averages, signalling a bearish technical outlook. Notably, investor participation has increased slightly, with delivery volumes rising by 4.49% on 20 Nov compared to the five-day average, indicating some active trading despite the price decline.

Fundamental Challenges Weighing on the Stock

Despite some positive attributes such as a high management efficiency reflected in a return on equity (ROE) of 18.67% and a low average debt-to-equity ratio of 0.06 times, West Coast Paper faces significant headwinds. The company is the second largest in its sector by market capitalisation at ₹2,790 crores, representing 14.20% of the sector, and its annual sales of ₹4,054.81 crores account for nearly 15% of the industry. However, these strengths have not translated into robust financial performance.

Operating profit has contracted at an annual rate of 3.24% over the last five years, signalling poor long-term growth. The company has reported negative results for eight consecutive quarters, with operating cash flow for the year at a low ₹156.52 crores. Quarterly profit after tax (PAT) has plummeted by 72.2% compared to the previous four-quarter average, standing at ₹17.49 crores. Meanwhile, interest expenses have surged by 33.43% over nine months to ₹33.73 crores, increasing financial strain.

Valuation metrics further dampen investor sentiment. The stock trades at a price-to-book value of 0.8, which is considered expensive relative to its peers’ historical averages, especially given its low ROE of 5.1%. This premium valuation is difficult to justify amid declining profitability and shrinking returns. Over the past year, profits have fallen by 60.7%, while the stock’s price has declined by 22.75%, underscoring the disconnect between valuation and earnings performance.

Comparative Performance and Investor Implications

West Coast Paper’s underperformance is evident not only against the Sensex but also relative to the broader BSE500 index over multiple time frames including one year, three years, and the last three months. This sustained lag highlights structural challenges within the company and the sector. While the stock has delivered a remarkable 140.64% return over five years, this figure is overshadowed by the 94.23% gain in the Sensex and the recent negative trends.

Investors should note that the stock’s liquidity is adequate for modest trade sizes, with a 2% threshold of the five-day average traded value equating to approximately ₹0.02 crores. However, the combination of deteriorating earnings, rising interest costs, and a valuation premium suggests caution. The recent price decline reflects market recognition of these fundamental weaknesses, despite the company’s sizeable market presence and efficient management.

In summary, West Coast Paper’s share price is falling due to a confluence of poor financial results, negative profit trends, and valuation concerns, all set against a backdrop of broader market gains. The stock’s inability to keep pace with sector and benchmark indices, coupled with rising costs and shrinking profitability, continues to weigh heavily on investor confidence.

Get 2 full years of MojoOne Premium for only Rs. 12,999. Subscribe for 1 year and we'll add another year FREE. Offer valid for a limited time. Start Saving Now →