Maithan Alloys Ltd. Rating Upgraded to Sell Amid Mixed Technical and Valuation Signals

Technical Trends: A Shift Towards Mild Bearishness

The primary driver behind the recent upgrade in Maithan Alloys’ rating is the change in its technical grade, which moved from mildly bullish to mildly bearish. This shift is underscored by a mixed set of technical indicators. On a weekly basis, the Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD) remains mildly bullish, but the monthly MACD has turned bearish, signalling weakening momentum over the longer term.

Relative Strength Index (RSI) readings on both weekly and monthly charts show no clear signals, indicating a lack of strong directional momentum. Meanwhile, Bollinger Bands have turned bearish on both weekly and monthly timeframes, suggesting increased volatility and downward pressure on the stock price.

Daily moving averages also reflect a mildly bearish stance, while the Know Sure Thing (KST) indicator presents a bearish weekly trend but a bullish monthly trend, highlighting conflicting signals across time horizons. Dow Theory assessments further complicate the picture, with weekly trends mildly bullish but monthly trends mildly bearish. On-balance volume (OBV) shows no trend weekly but a bullish monthly pattern, indicating some accumulation over the longer term despite short-term selling pressure.

These mixed technical signals have contributed to a cautious upgrade in the rating, recognising some stabilisation but also persistent risks in the stock’s price action.

Valuation: From Fair to Attractive

Valuation metrics have improved notably, prompting an upgrade from a fair to an attractive valuation grade. Maithan Alloys currently trades at a price-to-earnings (PE) ratio of 6.48, significantly lower than the Indian Metals industry average of 17.83, indicating the stock is undervalued relative to its peers.

The price-to-book (P/B) value stands at 0.70, suggesting the stock is trading below its book value, which may appeal to value investors. Enterprise value to EBIT (EV/EBIT) and EV to EBITDA ratios are 6.30 and 5.54 respectively, both reflecting a relatively inexpensive valuation compared to industry norms.

Other valuation indicators include an EV to capital employed ratio of 0.48 and EV to sales of 0.54, reinforcing the stock’s attractive pricing. The PEG ratio is 0.00, which, while unusual, may reflect zero or negative earnings growth expectations factored into the price.

Dividend yield is modest at 1.61%, while return on capital employed (ROCE) and return on equity (ROE) stand at 7.57% and 10.79% respectively, indicating moderate efficiency in generating returns from capital and equity.

Financial Trend: Weakness Persists Despite Valuation Appeal

Despite the improved valuation and technical signals, Maithan Alloys’ recent financial performance remains a concern. The company reported very negative results for Q2 FY25-26, with net sales falling by 22.38% year-on-year. Operating profit has declined at an annualised rate of -2.65% over the past five years, signalling weak long-term growth prospects.

Profit before tax (PBT) excluding other income for the quarter stood at ₹12.23 crores, down 70.2% compared to the previous four-quarter average. More alarmingly, the company posted a net loss (PAT) of ₹120.95 crores for the quarter, a steep decline of 168.2% relative to the prior four-quarter average.

The operating profit to interest coverage ratio has dropped to a low of 2.30 times, indicating reduced ability to service debt comfortably, although the company maintains a low average debt-to-equity ratio of zero, which mitigates some financial risk.

Over the past year, Maithan Alloys’ stock price has declined by 1.74%, underperforming the BSE Sensex which gained 8.01% over the same period. The stock has also consistently underperformed the BSE500 index in each of the last three annual periods, reflecting persistent challenges in market sentiment and company fundamentals.

Quality Assessment: Mixed Signals from Market Participation and Returns

Quality metrics for Maithan Alloys remain mixed. The company’s Mojo Score is 31.0, with a Mojo Grade of Sell, upgraded from Strong Sell. This score reflects the combined impact of valuation, technicals, financial trends, and quality factors.

Notably, domestic mutual funds hold no stake in the company, which may indicate a lack of confidence from institutional investors who typically conduct thorough on-the-ground research. This absence of institutional backing could be a red flag for some investors.

However, the company’s long-term returns tell a more nuanced story. Over a 10-year horizon, Maithan Alloys has delivered an impressive 1009.74% return, far outpacing the Sensex’s 241.83% gain. Over five years, the stock has returned 56.64%, slightly below the Sensex’s 65.06%. Yet, over shorter periods such as one year and three years, the stock has underperformed significantly, with returns of -1.74% and -11.47% respectively, compared to Sensex gains of 8.01% and 35.12%.

This divergence suggests that while the company has demonstrated strong long-term growth, recent years have been challenging, impacting investor confidence and quality perceptions.

Market Price and Volatility Context

Maithan Alloys’ current market price stands at ₹991.00, down 3.55% on the day from a previous close of ₹1,027.50. The stock’s 52-week high is ₹1,265.00, while the 52-week low is ₹834.05, indicating a wide trading range and significant volatility over the past year.

Today’s trading range was between ₹981.45 and ₹1,032.65, reflecting intraday volatility consistent with the broader technical uncertainty. The stock’s recent weekly return of -11.74% has underperformed the Sensex’s -1.77% return, though it has outperformed over the past month with a 5.56% gain versus the Sensex’s -3.56% decline.

Conclusion: A Cautious Upgrade Reflecting Valuation Appeal Amid Financial Headwinds

The upgrade of Maithan Alloys Ltd.’s investment rating from Strong Sell to Sell reflects a cautious optimism driven primarily by improved valuation metrics and a nuanced technical outlook. While the company’s stock is attractively priced relative to its peers, and some technical indicators suggest potential stabilisation, significant financial challenges remain.

Investors should weigh the company’s very negative recent quarterly results, weak operating profit growth, and underperformance against benchmarks over the medium term against its attractive valuation and long-term return history. The absence of institutional ownership further underscores the need for careful due diligence.

Overall, Maithan Alloys presents a complex investment case where value and risk coexist, warranting a Sell rating with close monitoring of upcoming financial results and market developments.

Upgrade at special rates, valid only for the next few days. Claim Your Special Rate →