Is Maruti Sec. overvalued or undervalued?

Understanding Maruti Sec.’s Valuation Metrics

At first glance, Maruti Sec.’s price-to-earnings (PE) ratio stands at an unusually low figure, which might typically indicate undervaluation. However, this figure is distorted by the company’s negative book value, reflected in its price-to-book (P/B) ratio being negative. Such a scenario often signals accounting anomalies or financial distress, complicating straightforward valuation interpretations.

Further scrutiny reveals the enterprise value (EV) multiples, including EV to EBIT and EV to EBITDA, both hovering below 4. This might suggest the stock is trading at a discount relative to earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortisation. Yet, the EV to capital employed ratio is exceptionally high, indicating that the market values the company’s capital base at a premium, possibly due to expectations of future growth or profitability.

Return on capital employed (ROCE) is extraordinarily high, exceeding 1100%, which is an outlier figure that warrants caution. Such a number may be influenced by accounting treatments or one-off gains rather than sustainable operational performance. Meanwhile, return on equity (ROE) is negative, consistent with the negative book value, signalling challenges in generating shareholder returns.

Peer Comparison and Relative Valuation

When compared with peers in the NBFC sector, Maruti Sec. is classified as very expensive, despite its anomalous valuation ratios. Other companies in the sector, such as Bajaj Finance and Jio Financial, also carry very expensive tags but exhibit more conventional valuation metrics with positive PE and PEG ratios. Meanwhile, some peers like Life Insurance and SBI Life Insurance are rated very attractive or fair, reflecting more balanced valuations relative to their earnings and growth prospects.

Maruti Sec.’s PEG ratio is zero, which is unusual and suggests either no expected earnings growth or data irregularities. This contrasts with peers whose PEG ratios range from moderate to high, indicating varying growth expectations priced into their shares.

Stock Price Performance and Market Sentiment

Over the past year, Maruti Sec. has delivered an extraordinary return exceeding 400%, vastly outperforming the Sensex benchmark, which returned just over 5% in the same period. This stellar performance has likely contributed to the stock’s very expensive valuation grade. However, recent price movements show a slight pullback, with the current price below the previous close and trading well below its 52-week high, suggesting some profit-taking or market caution.

Short-term returns over one week and one month have been negative, while the Sensex has shown modest gains, indicating a divergence in investor sentiment. Long-term returns over five and ten years remain exceptional, underscoring the company’s past growth trajectory but not necessarily its current valuation justification.

Is Maruti Sec. Overvalued or Undervalued?

Despite the superficially low PE and EV multiples, Maruti Sec.’s valuation is best characterised as very expensive. The negative book value and negative ROE raise red flags about the company’s financial health and sustainability of earnings. The extremely high ROCE figure appears to be an outlier and should be treated with caution rather than as a sign of operational excellence.

Moreover, the stock’s classification as very expensive by valuation grading systems, combined with its recent price correction and peer comparisons, suggests that the market has priced in significant expectations for future performance that may be difficult to meet. Investors should be wary of the risks associated with such a valuation, especially given the company’s financial peculiarities.

For those considering exposure to the NBFC sector, it may be prudent to explore alternatives with more stable fundamentals and attractive valuations. While Maruti Sec. has delivered exceptional long-term returns, its current price level reflects a premium that may not be justified by underlying financial metrics.

Conclusion

Maruti Sec. currently trades at a valuation level that is very expensive relative to its peers and historical benchmarks. The company’s unusual financial ratios and negative equity base complicate traditional valuation analysis, but the consensus points towards overvaluation rather than undervaluation. Investors should approach the stock with caution and consider diversifying into other NBFCs or sectors offering better risk-reward profiles.

Limited Time Only! Subscribe for Rs. 12,999 and get 1 Year of MojoOne + an Additional Year Completely FREE. Don't miss out on this exclusive offer. Claim Your Free Year →