Why is Modern Shares & Stockbrokers Ltd ?
1
Weak Long Term Fundamental Strength with an average Return on Equity (ROE) of 2.30%
- Poor long term growth as Net Sales has grown by an annual rate of 9.44%
2
Flat results in Sep 25
3
With ROE of 1.9, it has a Very Expensive valuation with a 0.9 Price to Book Value
- The stock is trading at a premium compared to its peers' average historical valuations
- Over the past year, while the stock has generated a return of -23.44%, its profits have fallen by -20%
4
Underperformed the market in the last 1 year
- Even though the market (BSE500) has generated returns of 2.06% in the last 1 year, the stock has hugely underperformed and has generate negative returns of -23.44% returns
How much should you sell?
- All quantity irrespective of whether you are making profits or losses
(If sector exposure > 30%, please use optimiser tool to see which are the best stocks to hold in Non Banking Financial Company (NBFC))
When to re-enter? - We will constantly monitor the company and review our call based on new data
Is Modern Shares for you?
High Risk, Low Return
Absolute
Risk Adjusted
Volatility
Modern Shares
-23.44%
-0.39
59.46%
Sensex
4.7%
0.40
11.83%
Valuation Key Factors 
Factor
Value
P/E Ratio
49
Industry P/E
85
Price to Book Value
0.94
EV to EBIT
0.38
EV to EBITDA
0.38
EV to Capital Employed
0.34
EV to Sales
0.10
PEG Ratio
NA
Dividend Yield
NA
ROCE (Latest)
44.14%
ROE (Latest)
1.92%
Loading Valuation Snapshot...
Technical key factors
Indicator
Weekly
Monthly
MACD
Mildly Bullish
Mildly Bearish
RSI
Bullish
No Signal
Bollinger Bands
Sideways
Mildly Bearish
Moving Averages
Bearish (Daily)
KST
Mildly Bullish
Mildly Bearish
Dow Theory
No Trend
No Trend
Technical Movement
3What is working for the Company
PAT(Latest six months)
Higher at Rs 0.31 cr
PBDIT(Q)
Highest at Rs 0.27 cr.
0What is not working for the Company
NO KEY NEGATIVE TRIGGERS
Loading Valuation Snapshot...
Here's what is working for Modern Shares
Profit After Tax (PAT) - Latest six months
Higher at Rs 0.31 cr
than preceding 12 month period ended Sep 2025 of Rs 0.21 crMOJO Watch
In the half year the company has already crossed PAT of the previous twelve months
PAT (Rs Cr)
Operating Profit (PBDIT) - Quarterly
Highest at Rs 0.27 cr.
in the last five quartersMOJO Watch
Near term Operating Profit trend is positive
Operating Profit (Rs Cr)






